Economy, markets and the environment

The role of government in the economy is one of the most contested areas of policy, and the argument tends to revive whenever economies perform poorly and fail the people who depend on them, above all through the labour market. This programme examines that role across monetary, fiscal, labour-market and trade policy; competition and the regulation of monopoly, including the record of privatised network industries such as water; industrial strategy and whether the state should own industry; and the condition of Britain’s infrastructure. It treats energy and the natural world together, because choices in each constrain the other. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change concludes that “it is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land” (IPCC, 2021); the real choices lie in what responding will cost, and who will bear the cost. Taxation, the subject of our first priority review, runs through all of it: it touches every productive and consumptive decision, and the UK system has, in our assessment, accreted piecemeal with little regard to its coherence. The Mirrlees review, Tax by Design (Institute for Fiscal Studies, 2011), remains the most authoritative diagnosis available, and our review takes it as its starting point.

Questions we are pursuing

  • What should a coherent tax system look like, and why have the central findings of the 2011 Mirrlees review not been carried into policy?

  • What should the fiscal rules be for, and do the present rules serve that purpose?

  • Can monopolies be regulated effectively, and has privatisation of network industries worked?

  • Should government make industrial policy, and if so, of what kind?

  • How will Britain keep the lights on while reducing its combustion of fossil fuels?

  • What will responding to climate change cost, and who should bear the cost?

Priority reviews

  • Taxation: central to state capacity and to every productive and consumptive decision; the most complex and least coherently designed UK system reviewed.