Climate change: science, costs and policy

"Is the climate crisis real?" is three questions. Is the climate changing? Are human activities the main cause? And what will it cost to respond, and who will bear the cost?

What the science establishes

The first two questions have clear answers. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change concludes that "it is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land" (IPCC, 2021). The largest share of greenhouse-gas emissions comes from carbon dioxide from burning fossil fuels and from industry, followed by methane; global emissions in 2019 were about 54 per cent higher than in 1990 (IPCC, 2023).

Science is always open to revision by new evidence. That is a reason to keep testing the evidence, not a reason to treat a strong consensus as a weak one.

Where the real choices lie

The third question is where the choices are made, and where public debate has been least disciplined. In our view the costs of reducing emissions will be large, and unevenly shared: between countries, between generations, and between taxpayers, consumers and savers. We ask:

  • What will each route to lower emissions cost, and who will pay for it?

  • Which instruments (carbon pricing, regulation, subsidy or public investment in new technology) achieve the greatest reduction for each pound spent?

  • How should costs be shared fairly, at home and between nations?

  • How can the choices be explained to the public clearly and dispassionately, so that consent is earned rather than assumed?

Our aim is independent, evidence-based analysis of these questions, keeping what the science establishes apart from what remains a matter of political and economic choice.