XPLN: the fourth estate

Reimagining the fourth estate: the case for XPLN Media

Neither our political institutions nor our news institutions have kept pace with the challenges Britain faces. The entangled crises of the polycrisis are too serious to be reduced to partisan point-scoring, yet the short-term theatre of reflexive opposition has crowded out the deliberative side of politics: the consultation, consideration and cooperation that issues outlasting a parliament require. Dialogue, debate and dissent remain essential to decision-making in an open, liberal, democratic society. What has weakened is the space in which they inform one another.

The economics of news. News media face pressure on both supply and demand. Sales of national and local printed newspapers fell by roughly half between 2007 and 2017, and digital advertising has not replaced the revenue lost (Cairncross 2019). At the same time, the sources of news have multiplied: anyone with a smartphone can report, and news now mingles with commentary and social interaction on the same platforms. Whether this strengthens democratic institutions is an open question. We believe that it can, but that, as presently packaged and consumed, it does not.

The economics of attention. Faced with so many sources, consumers ration the time they give any one. Brevity and simplicity win over clarity and complexity: "A wins, B loses" is easier to present and to grasp than the interwoven strands of a nuanced reality, even when it is wrong. Zero-sum framing earns clicks. The common fear that algorithms seal people into echo chambers is overstated: research finds such chambers much less widespread than is commonly assumed (Ross Arguedas et al. 2022). The more serious effect is on the outlets themselves, which must serve shrinking attention with fewer resources.

The poverty of left and right. A single spectrum from left to right no longer describes the range of political opinion in most democracies, if it ever did. Describing politics in those terms flattens real distinctions and damages civic discourse. Better descriptions would need politically literate journalists and an audience interested in the distinctions they draw.

The fourth estate. In his lecture on the hero as man of letters, delivered in 1840, Thomas Carlyle recalled Burke's three estates of Parliament and added that in the reporters' gallery "there sat a Fourth Estate more important far than they all" (Carlyle 1841). The phrase recognises the press as part of the balance of powers that keeps a free state free; for Montesquieu, liberty required that "le pouvoir arrête le pouvoir", that power check power (Montesquieu 1748, XI, 4). Without an active press that informs the public, the link between political action and informed electoral judgement, on which democracy depends, is lost.

What is needed. To restore that check, we need a format free of the legacy technology and cost base of traditional news. Rather than seeking balance within each report, it should accept the diversity of sources available to everyone, and bring together diverse viewpoints to sort, analyse, interpret and criticise them. It should present that diversity to the attentive public engagingly, and let the audience take part through the online tools now available.

That is what XPLN Media is designed to do.

References

  • Cairncross, F. (2019) The Cairncross Review: A Sustainable Future for Journalism. London: Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, 12 February. GOV.UK

  • Carlyle, T. (1841) On Heroes, Hero-Worship, and the Heroic in History, lecture V, delivered 19 May 1840. Project Gutenberg

  • Montesquieu (1748) De l'esprit des lois, book XI, chapter 4.

  • Ross Arguedas, A., Robertson, C. T., Fletcher, R. and Nielsen, R. K. (2022) Echo Chambers, Filter Bubbles, and Polarisation: A Literature Review. Oxford: Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism.

Previous: XPLN Media · Contents · Next: ProSPEc